Switch to ADA Accessible Theme
Close Menu
West Palm Beach Criminal Lawyer / Blog / Drug Crimes / How Can A Drug-Sniffing Dog’s Alert Affect My Case?

How Can A Drug-Sniffing Dog’s Alert Affect My Case?

DogSniff

In September 2026, a K-9 dog and his handler were able to stop a drug dealer fleeing after they tried to serve a warrant on him in Daytona Beach. They visited the man’s motel room, but when they attempted to serve the warrant, the suspect fled. The dog, however, was able to locate and bring down the individual a few blocks away, who was then found to have crack cocaine in his pocket. While that suspect gave probable cause to arrest him by fleeing, it can be more difficult to determine whether probable cause exists and searches are valid if the only evidence is a drug dog’s alert.

Usually (But Not Always) Admissible

Evidence uncovered by drug dogs is generally admissible. The U.S. Supreme Court held in Florida v Harris (2013) that if it can be shown that a dog is reliable in terms of training and reliability, their alert might signify to a reasonably prudent person that criminal activity was happening. However, there are several caveats in that ruling, and if the dog has a reputation for unreliability, or other evidence exists that might explain an alert, the dog’s sniff may not be ruled admissible.

In addition to trying to argue that a dog is unreliable, a good defense attorney will also bring up the possibility of any event that might have ‘pushed’ the dog to alert without any illegal substances being present. For example, did the handler’s body language signify the presence of drugs even if the dog did not smell them? Is it possible that there was a residual scent from where an illegal substance used to be?

Cannabis Cases Are Different

If you have been charged with a drug offense based on the alert of a drug-sniffing dog, the best way to attack that evidence is often to look for the records. If a dog has been working in this arena for a long time, there will be evidence of its successes and failures, and of the training methods used. It may be that an expert’s testimony is required, or the testimony of the handler may also prove illuminating. Your attorney will have many tools in the proverbial box to create reasonable doubt in your case.

One important caveat that Florida defendants should keep in mind, in the advent of recent rulings from the Courts of Appeals, is that as of this writing, the mere smell of cannabis is no longer sufficient to determine probable cause for a search (whether smelled by a man or a dog). While medical cannabis is legal in Florida, recreational use is not. However, few if any dogs can adequately differentiate between legal and illegal cannabis products with any degree of accuracy. Thus, sniff evidence has become less persuasive in these types of cases.

Contact A West Palm Beach Drug Offenses Attorney

Being charged with a drug offense can be scary, especially if you have never been in trouble with the law before. We are ready to try and assist – call a West Palm Beach drug offenses attorney from Perlet & Shiner, P.A. today to schedule a consultation.

Source:

https://www.wfla.com/top-videos/watch-k-9-chases-man-fleeing-florida-motel-room-with-drugs-deputies-say/

Facebook Twitter LinkedIn